Compare publisher evidence

This worksheet stays in your browser. It does not fetch websites, verify claims, buy links or save to your account. Download JSON to keep your work.

Fictional teaching comparison. These publishers, evidence references and observations are invented. Edited examples keep this label until the review is cleared.

Set the destination, reader goal and market. Add up to eight candidates, record evidence for each area, then make your own decision. Counts describe your records, not link quality or ranking potential.

Reader goal and purpose
Help model-building beginners choose paint for their first project.
Audience, language and market
English-speaking hobby readers; no country-level reach verified.
Destination URL
https://shop.example.com/guides/model-painting

Repeated publisher domains

Specialist tutorial

https://models.example.org/

https://models.example.org/tutorial/painting

Recorded checks: Unknown: 1 · Supported by recorded evidence: 5 · Concern recorded: 0

Your decision

Shortlisted by reviewer

Shortlist for a small reader-focused test; the metric gap remains explicit. This is a human judgment, not a ranking prediction.

Example reviewer · 2026-10-25

Audience fit

Supported by recorded evidence

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q01/1
Observation and limitations
Recent beginner tutorials discuss the same painting problem.

Editorial evidence

Supported by recorded evidence

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q01/2
Observation and limitations
The sampled tutorial contains an attributed test and original process photos.

Placement and qualification

Supported by recorded evidence

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q01/3
Observation and limitations
A visible resource sentence and sponsored qualification are specified in the fictional brief.

Metrics and provenance

Unknown

Checked on (UTC date)
—
Evidence reference / method
—
Observation and limitations
No licensed metric export was provided. Keep unknown rather than entering zero.

Technical evidence

Supported by recorded evidence

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q01/5
Observation and limitations
The fictional source check returned readable HTML and the intended href; indexing was not checked.

Terms and maintenance

Supported by recorded evidence

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q01/6
Observation and limitations
The fictional offer specifies 30 days, USD 1 and a named issue contact; renewal is separate.

General-interest portal

https://general.example.net/

Leave blank if the actual placement page is unknown.

Recorded checks: Unknown: 3 · Supported by recorded evidence: 2 · Concern recorded: 1

Your decision

Declined by reviewer

Decline for this audience: the large domain score does not resolve the topic mismatch.

Example reviewer · 2026-10-25

Audience fit

Concern recorded

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q02/1
Observation and limitations
The sampled audience is interested in celebrity news, with no demonstrated connection to model painting.

Editorial evidence

Supported by recorded evidence

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q02/2
Observation and limitations
A named editor and correction contact are present in the fictional sample.

Placement and qualification

Unknown

Checked on (UTC date)
—
Evidence reference / method
—
Observation and limitations
The actual source page and link position have not been supplied.

Metrics and provenance

Supported by recorded evidence

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q02/4
Observation and limitations
Fictional Ahrefs DR 80 snapshot dated 2026-09-30, domain scope. It does not establish page readership or fit.

Technical evidence

Unknown

Checked on (UTC date)
—
Evidence reference / method
—
Observation and limitations
No source URL is available to inspect.

Terms and maintenance

Unknown

Checked on (UTC date)
—
Evidence reference / method
—
Observation and limitations
Duration, removal and issue handling remain unanswered.

Repeated footer on the specialist site

https://news.models.example.org/

https://news.models.example.org/archive

Recorded checks: Unknown: 3 · Supported by recorded evidence: 2 · Concern recorded: 1

Your decision

Needs research

Ask for exact pages, qualification, duration and removal terms before deciding.

·

Audience fit

Supported by recorded evidence

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q03/1
Observation and limitations
The site covers the same hobby as the destination.

Editorial evidence

Unknown

Checked on (UTC date)
—
Evidence reference / method
—
Observation and limitations
No specific article or editor is attached to the footer proposal.

Placement and qualification

Concern recorded

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q03/3
Observation and limitations
The offer repeats a footer on 50 pages of the same domain. Fifty placements are not fifty independent publishers.

Metrics and provenance

Unknown

Checked on (UTC date)
—
Evidence reference / method
—
Observation and limitations
The offered authority badge has no provider or date.

Technical evidence

Supported by recorded evidence

Checked on (UTC date)
2026-10-24
Evidence reference / method
Q03/5
Observation and limitations
The fictional footer check finds the href on one page; coverage of the other 49 is unverified.

Terms and maintenance

Unknown

Checked on (UTC date)
—
Evidence reference / method
—
Observation and limitations
The removal process and precise duration have not been confirmed.